Construction Contract Dispute Resolution: What Do You Prefer?

In presentations I often mention that every construction contract is the beginning of a construction dispute.  The same usually applies to architects agreements and other design contracts too.  With that in mind, I'd like to hear from you.  What terms do you prefer in your contracts for resolving disputes: nothing, mediation, arbitration?  Vote below.  And add a comment to elaborate on your vote...

 

 

 

Economic Loss Rule: Arizona Applies It to Construction Claims

Partial Wall From an Old Brick Building in the AmericanSouthwestThe Arizona Supreme Court applied the economic loss rule (the "ELR") to bar a construction related claim for the first time last week. 

Overly simplified, the ELR is a judge-made rule that bars many extra-contractual claims for design and construction defects when those claims seek only damages for the cost to repair or replace defective work, not damages for death, personal injury, or damage to other property.

In Flagstaff Affordable Housing Limited Partnership v. Design Alliance, Inc.  the Justices applied the ELR to deny an owner's claim against their architect for negligent design of an affordable housing project in Flagstaff, Arizona.

Continue Reading...

Construction Claims and Cases On The Rise

Owner Pointing Finger at Contractor in Construction DisputeIn Building Overrun Cases on the Rise, journalist Ed Hammond at the Financial Times reports that late completion disputes are already rising this year in the UK.  He also mentions:

  • With projects started in better times now yielding lower occupancy and returns, owners are more inclined to pursue claims against their contractors
     
  • Liquidated damages claims for late completion are rising in frequency and amount
     
  • Austere times and pressure on margins are compelling owners and contractors to become more contentious and adversarial
     
  • The Construction Products Association predicts a 3% decrease in spending for 2010

Will these tends continue in the in the UK?  Will they cross the Atlantic to North America too?

As construction disputes intensify and relationships become more strained, your contracts will come under more scrutiny.  Are you and your contracts fortified for that?

Green Construction Curb Appeal: Looks Matter

Honeycomb Solar UV Ray Gathering Cell PanelsIn Overcoming the Ugly Factor in Building-Integrated Solar Design, journalist Jennifer Kho reports on how Skidmore Ownings, & Merril and the Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute are collaborating to make solar energy-gathering materials look better.

One source says "most applications thus far are pretty ugly and impede your view."  

While visual elegance may not seem like a serious concern to those determined to generate electricity from the sun, for architects and developers looking to sell or rent properties, looks matter.

The SOM/Rensselaer collaboration is focusing on a dynamic solar facade, a panel composed of glass elements like the one to the right.  In its current design, it's hung on wires that move up and down and twist from side to side to track the sun.  The idea is to produce a system that combines aesthetic appeal with more efficient capturing of the sun's UV radiation.

Engineers and designers recognize that for building owners and operators who must rent and sell property to meet pro formas and satisfy investors and lenders, energy efficiency and government incentives aren't the only factors in the green building calculus.  Like it or not, curb appeal attracts tenants and buyers.  The engineers and designers are addressing that factor too. 

 

Real Estate and Construction in Chicago: Crain's Sobering Video Forecast

Focusing locally today on my own hometown, this Crain's broadcast offers a sobering forecast for the Chicagoland residential real estate and construction markets.  Do you agree?  Watch the video, vote, and elaborate by posting a comment using the link below below.

 

Arbitration Waived by Demand to Foreclose Mechanics Lien

Stenciled Stamp: WAIVEDJudges to owner: demanding that your contractor foreclose their mechanics lien within 30 days or lose it forever waives your right to require arbitration.

 

The Backstory of Illinois Concrete-I.C.I., Inc. v. Storefitters, Inc.

Unfortunately, the Illinois Appellate Court (Second District) decision in Illinois Concrete-I.C.I., Inc. v. Storefitters, Inc. (PDF) doesn't give us too many background details.  Here's what we can gather: an owner entered into a contract with a contractor to provide some type of construction work for the owner.  The contract had an arbitration clause, presumably one that says that if the owner and the contractor get into a dispute, they must submit the dispute to binding arbitration instead of resorting to the courts.

The owner and the contractor got into a dispute.  The owner didn't pay.  So the contractor recorded a lien against the property they'd worked on.

Under Section 34 of the Illinois Mechanics Lien Act (PDF) an owner (and others too) can serve a written demand on anyone holding a mechanics lien against their property (a "mechanics lien holder") demanding that the mechanics lien holder sue to foreclose their mechanics lien within 30 days (a "Section 34 demand").  And if the mechanics lien claimant doesn't go to the clerk of the court and file their foreclosure complaint before that 30 days expires, the mechanics lien claimant forfeits their lien.

Continue Reading...

Green Building Surge

AuggieV Logo from Green Building CT BlogAuggieV over at Building Green CT reports a Recent Surge In Connecticut Green Building News May Be A Good Sign.  Some of the things he mentions:

  • Connecticut tied with Georgia for No. 1 in the fifth annual Global Green USA analysis and ranking of state Qualified Allocation Plans used by state housing finance agencies and guide annual distribution of federal Low-Income Housing Tax Credits
  • Reckson (a division of SL Green Realty Corp.) installed a new 100 kilowatt photovoltaic solar panel system on the roof of their facility on Greenwich
  • The state of Connecticut and Gateway Community College just broke ground on a $198M campus in downtown New Haven.  It's the largest construction project the state undertaken to date and its first public building designed gold LEED certification. The project is also estimated to employ 350 workers
  • Nestle Waters North America announced they will move their headquarters from Greenwich to Stamford in late 2010. The company plans to renovate the new Stamford headquarters for LEED certification. They've already got nine LEED certified facilities. The Connecticut Department of Economic and Community Development is providing a $4M low-interest loan to equip the new building and Nestle Waters is also eligible for up to $5 million in tax credits